The last execution by firing squad in the United States occurred on June 18, 2010, when Ronnie Lee Gardner was executed at the Utah State Correctional Facility in Draper. Five volunteer officers fired simultaneously at a target over his heart. Utah remains the only state that still authorizes firing squads as a backup method today, though no execution by the method has occurred since.

The 2010 execution was not a relic of the frontier era. It was a deliberate legal choice made by a condemned man in the twenty-first century, and it required the state to maintain a protocol most corrections departments never build. Understanding why it happened requires looking at how the method works, how courts have repeatedly examined it, and why it keeps returning to death penalty debates nearly 150 years after Utah's first firing squad execution in 1877.

How the Firing Squad Mechanism Works

The modern firing squad is engineered around a single problem: nobody in the firing line should know who fired the fatal round. Utah's written protocol, filed in federal court during Gardner's appeals, specifies five shooters positioned behind a slotted wall at a distance of roughly 25 feet. At the command to fire, all five pull heavy-loaded single-action revolvers. One of the five rifles is traditionally loaded with a blank or an underloaded cartridge, a practice intended to create doubt in each shooter's mind about culpability.

Aim is directed at a target pinned over the heart, typically a circular cloth marker. The volley is meant to destroy the heart and major thoracic vessels, causing rapid unconsciousness through sudden loss of blood pressure to the brain. A physician then checks for a heartbeat and respiration. If life remains, the procedure allows for a follow-up volley, though this has been rare or unnecessary in the executions that followed the modern protocol.

The reason the heart rather than the head is targeted is largely visual, not ballistic. A head shot at close range is more immediately fatal but produces graphic injury the witnesses and the state prefer to avoid. Chest fire, by contrast, looks more clinical, even though a marksman can miss a moving or settling target.

Why five shooters instead of four or six? The odd number matters. An even firing line could split ambiguously. Five guarantees a majority of live rounds after the blank is included, which makes the volley statistically more reliable in a crowd of untrained volunteers. The blank also serves a psychological function for the firing officers, who are drawn from the department's ranks.

The Gardner Execution, Quantified

Ronnie Lee Gardner was sentenced for the 1984 murder of attorney Michael Burdell during a courthouse escape attempt. He spent more than two decades on death row, and his case became famous for his decision to choose firing squad over lethal injection when Utah law offered him the option. At the start of the execution, he was 49 years old.

The event involved several hard numbers. Gardner was shot at roughly 12:15 a.m. local time. Wearing a black jumpsuit, he was strapped to a black metal chair with a target over his chest. Five uniformed officers fired a volley that multiple accounts describe as nearly simultaneous. He was pronounced dead approximately two minutes after the order to fire. A crowd of roughly 200 gathered outside the prison to protest, and the execution drew national media attention despite being a single event.

The execution received also, by any accounting, more public scrutiny than a typical lethal injection. The chief justice of the Utah Supreme Court had previously described firing squad as having a "certain panache," a remark that surfaced repeatedly in coverage and in the court's later jurisprudence. Gardner's final statement included the word "I love you" repeated several times, and he reportedly drank red wine in his last hours, which softens the chill of the method itself.

The rate of firing squad executions in US history is worth citing because it contextualizes how rare the 2010 event was. Roughly 150 documented civilian executions by firing squad occurred in the United States across the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, almost entirely in Utah. Utah carried out the overwhelming majority. Two other states used it in a single instance each, and Nevada's last firing squad execution was in 1913. That means between the end of the nineteenth century and 2010, the method survived almost exclusively in one state.

A Timeline of the American Firing Squad

For a method presumed obsolete, the firing squad has a remarkably stable timeline. The table below compresses the key milestones.

Year Event Significance
1877 First documented Utah firing squad execution Establishes territorial precedent
1913 Nevada's last known firing squad execution Method fades outside Utah
1976 Supreme Court reinstates capital punishment (Gregg v. Georgia) Frameworks rebuilt state by state
1996 Utah renames execution method from "firing squad" to "fire squad" Semantics in statute
2004 Utah law amended to limit firing squad choice Only inmates sentenced before 2004 retain option
2010 Ronnie Lee Gardner executed by firing squad Last US firing squad execution to date
2015 Utah reauthorizes firing squad as backup Triggered if lethal injection drugs unavailable
2024-2025 Federal courts hear appeals from other Utah death row inmates Method revisited, no execution held

The 2004 amendment matters for understanding the modern legal picture. Utah grandfathered the firing squad for inmates already sentenced, which is precisely why Gardner's choice survived years of litigation. When Utah reauthorized the method in 2015 as a fallback, it reset the statutory framework: any future firing squad execution would happen only if the state could not obtain lethal injection drugs within a defined period.

Firing Squad Versus Lethal Injection

The comparison is unavoidable because the two methods compete for the same statutory role. Both are intended to produce death through a defined physiological mechanism. They differ in supply chain dependence, procedural visibility, and the degree to which the state can control the moment of death.

Feature Firing Squad Lethal Injection
Mechanism Massive chest trauma; rapid loss of circulation Anesthetic plus cardioplegic drug
Supply chain Firearms, ammunition, volunteers Pharmaceutical sourcing; foreign and compounding issues
Time to death About 2 minutes in reported cases Variable; 10-20 minutes or longer in problematic cases
Witness experience Graphic; volley and chair Appears clinical but requires monitoring
Procedure publication Utah filed written protocol in court Protocols often concealed
Legal challenges Method-of-choice claims; "unusual" arguments Drug access and pain claims
Historical use ~150, almost all Utah Standard since the 1980s

The supply chain difference is the actual hinge of policy. States adopted lethal injection partly to look humane. When drug manufacturers refused to sell products for executions in the 2010s, states found themselves unable to source reliable compounds. That shortage created the specific legal opening Utah's 2015 law addresses.

The counterintuitive detail is that lethal injection is not the more inherently reliable method. Autopsy data and litigation in multiple states have documented cases in which injected drugs failed to produce anesthesia, causing conscious pain. A firing squad is crude, but its mechanism of death is highly reliable when the volley is accurate. The controversy rests on the visual, not on the physiology.

Three misconceptions recur in coverage of the topic. The first is that a firing squad execution is constitutionally forbidden. The Supreme Court has never ruled the method itself unconstitutional. The 2010 Gardner litigation and earlier Utah appeals turned on procedure and protocol, not on a categorical ban. The Court's 2008 Baze v. Rees opinion, which examined lethal injection, set a standard focused on substantial risk of serious harm, and lower courts have applied it method by method.

The second misconception is that Gardner was the last person in the United States ever condemned to a firing squad. Several inmates remain on Utah's death row who chose or were sentenced to the method. Their executions simply have not occurred, so the count of pending cases is not zero. The distinction matters for anyone researching "the last execution" because the last one to occur and the last one to be possible are separate questions.

The third misconception is that the 2015 Utah law made firing squad the default method. It did not. Lethal injection remains the primary method under Utah law, with the rifle method as a fallback when the drug supply fails. That fallback was written narrowly, and the death penalty process has not yet produced a firing squad execution under it.

A related edge case is the blank cartridge. Some journalists have reported that the blank is a myth because fully loaded rifles in a five-gun volley would succeed without it. The blank is real as protocol, but its purpose is psychological. It does not change the ballistics of the four live rounds, and it does not reduce the risk of death if a live round is fired at a target over the heart.

Practical Actions for Researchers and Readers

For journalists, students, or anyone who wants to understand the firing squad question without relying on thin hearsay, the following concrete steps will produce a reliable answer:

Use primary documents: Utah Administrative Code and the court filings from Gardner v. Utah contain the actual protocol language and can be retrieved through public legal databases. Distinguish the last execution completed from the last scheduled and the last authorized; popular coverage often conflates them. Check court dockets after 2015 for method-of-execution appeals, because those cases carry the load of the legal debate. Ask state-level questions rather than federal ones; only Utah has a functioning statute, so national coverage is almost always derivative. Track drug sourcing as the supply-side variable that determines when a firing squad becomes the only available option.

One red flag deserves a bulleted warning, because it misleads many readers:

Claims of a "secret" firing squad execution are false; the executions that occurred were public and subject to press witness rules. Reports of the execution method being banned nationwide are unsupported; no Supreme Court ruling has eliminated it. Misreported dates, especially confusing Gardner's 2010 execution with a hypothetical future one, are common in low-quality summaries.

The practical test for a claim is simple. A true statement about the last US firing squad execution must name Gardell's case, a June 2010 date, a Utah venue, and a statutory basis that distinguishes the choice from the fallback law passed five years later. If a source fails any of these, it is likely recycled from an inferior summary.

The most important limit on the topic is that the law has not caught up to the technology or the supply reality. A firing squad execution could legally occur in Utah if lethal injection proves unavailable within the statutory window, but the trigger has not run. Nobody knows with precision how many inmates are currently positioned to exercise the choice, although Utah's death row contains several convicted persons whose cases predate the 2004 cutoff.

A second limit is evidentiary. Autopsy-based conclusions about firing squad deaths come from a small number of executions, and some historical accounts are not corroborated by official records. Any number about how often the follow-up volley was needed is therefore soft, and the responsible claim is that it was rare.

A third limit is constitutional. The Eighth Amendment's "evolving standards of decency" test has been argued in scholarship against firing squad, but lower courts have not adopted it in a controlling ruling. The method's continued legality is a patchwork of state statutes and one standing medical concern about the perception of cruelty.

A fourth limitation is comparative. Other countries with firing squad traditions have abolished or stopped using the method, but comparing the US with foreign practice is complicated by differences in how much procedure is published. The US standard is distinctive in how much of the protocol was disclosed through litigation.

A fifth limitation is the blank-round controversy. Courts have accepted the protocol's design, but no peer-reviewed study examines firing squad accuracy. The claim that the method is rapid and reliable rests on a small body of execution reports and on the physiology of penetrating cardiac wounds, which is textbook injury medicine.

Read together, the limits point to a conclusion: the last execution by firing squad in the US was a single well-documented event, but its legal importance outpaces its frequency. The method persists under law while lying dormant in practice; a single drug-sourcing failure could reverse that dormancy.

A practical note for further reading: follow the Utah Department of Corrections policy manual, which contains the protocol, and the case law on method selection. The topic rewards careful primary-source reading.

[High-stakes disclaimer: This article is general educational information about law and history, not legal advice, and it does not predict how any court would rule in a specific case. Executions remain legally regulated in the United States, and rules differ by state and change over time. For questions about a specific case, appeal, or statutory eligibility, consult a qualified attorney licensed in the relevant jurisdiction; for immediate safety emergencies, contact local emergency services.]

For medical, mental-health, self-harm or suicide, legal, financial/investment, insurance, tax, safety, or similarly high-stakes topics, make the final paragraph of the article a concise, topic-specific disclaimer. Say that the article is general educational information, not a diagnosis, treatment plan, legal opinion, or investment recommendation; do not promise outcomes or returns; and direct the reader to a qualified local professional. For immediate danger or self-harm risk, direct the reader to local emergency or crisis services. Keep this to 2-4 sentences, place it at the very end under the limitations discussion, and do not add a generic disclaimer to ordinary low-risk science articles. The disclaimer must supplement, not replace, the direct answer.